Here's a story the students had to read.
After the story is their essay prompt and the essay a student submitted.
It contains no details from the story, has some actual factual mistakes,
and sounds like it was written by an AI program.
Abuela Invents the Zero
Cofer, Judith Ortiz. (1996).
"You made me feel like a zero, like a nothing,” she says in Spanish, un cero, nada. She is trembling, an angry little old woman lost in a heavy winter coat that belongs to my mother. And I end up being sent to my room, like I was a child, to think about my grandmother’s idea of math.
It all began with Abuela coming up from the Island for a visit—her first time in the United States. My mother and father paid her way here so that she wouldn’t die without seeing snow, though if you asked me, and nobody has, the dirty slush in this city is not worth the price of a ticket. But I guess she deserves some kind of award for having had ten kids and survived to tell about it. My mother is the youngest of the bunch. Right up to the time when we’re supposed to pick up the old lady at the airport, my mother is telling me stories about how hard times were for la familia on la isla, and how la abuela worked night and day to support them after their father died of a heart attack. I’d die of a heart attack too if I had a troop like that to support. Anyway, I had seen her only three or four time in my entire life, whenever we would go for somebody’s funeral. I was born here and I have lived in this building all my life. But when Mami says, “Connie, please be nice to Abuela. She doesn’t have too many years left. Do you promise me, Constancia?”—when she uses my full name, I know she means business. So I say, “Sure.” Why wouldn’t I be nice? I’m not a monster, after all.
So we go to Kennedy to get la abuela, and she is the last to come out of the airplane, on the arm of the cabin attendant, all wrapped up in a black shawl. He hands her over to my parents like she was a package sent airmail. It is January, two feet of snow on the ground, and she’s wearing a shawl over a think black dress. That’s just the start.
Once home, she refuses to let my mother buy her a coat because it’s a waste of money for the two weeks she’ll be in el Polo Norte, as she calls New Jersey, the North Pole. So since she’s only four feet eleven inches tall, she walks around in my mother’s big black coat looking ridiculous. I try to walk far behind them in public so that no one will think we’re together. I plan to stay very busy the whole time she’s with us so that I won’t be asked to take her anywhere, but my plan is ruined where my mother comes down with the flu and Abuela absolutely has to attend Sunday mass or her soul will be eternally damned. She’s more Catholic than the Pope. My father decides that he should stay home with my mother and that I should escort la abuela to church. He tells me this on Saturday night as I’m getting ready to go out to the mall with my friends.
“No way,” I say.
I go for the car keys on the kitchen table: he usually leaves them there for me on Friday and Saturday nights. He beats me to them.
“No way,” he says, pocketing them and grinning at me.
Needless to say, we come to a compromise very quickly. I do have a responsibility to Sandra and Anita, who don’t drive yet. There is a Harley-Davidson fashion show at Brookline Square that we cannot miss.
“The mass in Spanish is at ten sharp tomorrow morning, entiendes?” My father is dangling the car keys in front of my nose and pulling them back when I try to reach for them. He’s really enjoying himself.
“I understand. Ten o’clock. I’m out of here.” I pry his fingers off the key ring. He knows that I’m late, so he makes it just a little difficult. Then he laughs. I run out of our apartment before he changes his mind. I have no idea what I’m getting myself into.
Sunday morning I have to walk two blocks on dirty snow to retrieve the car. I warm it up for Abuela as instructed by my parents, and drive it to the front of our building. My father walks her by the hand in baby steps on the slippery snow. The sight of her little head with a bun on top of it sticking out of that huge coat makes me want to run back into my room and get under the covers.
I just hope that nobody I know sees us together. I’m dreaming, of course. The mass is packed with people from our block. It’s a holy day of obligation and everyone I ever met is there.
I have to help her climb the steps, and she stops to take a deep breath after each one, then I lead her down the aisle so that everybody can see me with my bizarre grandmother. If I were a good Catholic, I’m sure I’d get some purgatory time taken off for my sacrifice. She is walking as slow as Captain Causteau exploring the bottom of the sea, looking around, taking her sweet time. Finally she chooses a pew, but she wants to sit in the other end. It’s like she had a spot picked out for some unknown reason, and although it’s the most inconvenient seat in the house, that’s where she has to sit. So we squeeze by all the people already sitting there, saying, “Excuse me, please, con permiso, pardon me,” getting annoyed looks the whole way. By the time we settle in, I’m drenched in sweat. I keep my head down like I’m praying so as not to see or be seen. She is praying loud, in Spanish, and singing hymns at the top of her creaky voice.
I ignore her when she gets up with a hundred other people to go take communion. I’m actually praying hard now—that this will all be over soon. But the next time I look up, I see a black coat dragging around and around the church, stopping here and there so a little gray head can peek out like a periscope on a submarine. There are giggles in the church, and even the priest has frozen in the middle of a blessing, his hands above his head like he is about to lead the congregation in a set of jumping jacks.
I realize to my horror that my grandmother is lost. She can’t find her way back to the pew. I am so embarrassed that even though the woman next to me is shooting daggers at me with her eyes, I just can’t move to go get her. I put my hands over my face like I’m praying, but it’s really to hide my burning cheeks. I would like for her to disappear. I just know that on Monday my friends, and my enemies, in the barrio will have a lot of senile-grandmother jokes to tell in front of me. I am frozen to my seat. So the same woman who wants me dead on the spot does it for me. She makes a big deal out of getting up and hurrying to get Abuela.
The rest of the mass is a blur. All I know is that my grandmother kneels the whole time with her hands over her face. She doesn’t speak to me on the way home, and she doesn’t let me help her walk, even though she almost falls a couple of times.
When we get to the apartment, my parents are at the kitchen table, where my mother is trying to eat some soup. They can see right away that something is wrong. Then Abuela points her finger at me like a judge passing a sentence on a criminal. She says in Spanish, “You made me feel like a zero, like a nothing.” Then she goes to her room.
I try to explain what happened. “I don’t understand why she’s so upset. She just got lost and wandered around for a while,” I tell them. But it sounds lame, even to my own ears. My mother gives me a look that makes me cringe and goes in to Abuela’s room to get her version of the story. She comes out with tears in her eyes.
“Your grandmother says to tell you that of all the hurtful things you can do to a person, the worst is to make them feel as if they are worth nothing.”
I can feel myself shrinking right there in front of her. But I can’t bring myself to tell my mother that I think I understand how I made Abuela feel. I might be sent into the old lady’s room to apologize, and it’s not easy to admit you’ve been a jerk—at least, not right away with everybody watching. So I just sit there not saying anything.
My mother looks at me for a long time, like she feels sorry for me. Then she says, “You should know, Constancia, that if it wasn’t for the old woman whose existence you don’t seem to value, you and I would not be here.”
That’s when I’m sent to my room to consider a number I hadn’t thought much about—until today.
Here's the assignment:
Choose ONE of these writing prompts to complete:
A. Write a letter that continues the story in which Constancia apologizes to Abuela and resolves the conflict between them. In your letter be sure to explain what Constancia has learned and how she has changed. Use flashbacks to illustrate the circumstances of their conflict and to show that Constancia has learned from her actions.
B: Write a scene that continues the story in which Constancia apologizes to Abuela and resolves the conflict between them, and explains what she has learned and how she has changed. Write your scene so that your word choice, sentence structure, and tone create a style similar to that of the story.
C: What lesson do you think Constancia has learned from this incident with her grandmother? Write a response to this question, and cite evidence from the text to support your response.
The student essay.
Forgiveness is a powerful act of kindness that can heal wounds and mend broken relationships. However, it is not always easy to forgive, especially when the offense has caused us significant pain or anger. In my case, I struggled to forgive my grandmother for her past behavior towards me. I had ignored her and been disrespectful to her, and it had caused a rift in our relationship. But as time passed, I realized that forgiveness was necessary for both of us to move on.
At first, I found it hard to forgive my grandmother. I felt that she had done wrong to me and did not deserve my forgiveness. But as I reflected on the situation, I realized that holding a grudge was not helping me. It was causing me to feel angry and resentful towards my grandmother, and it was affecting my other relationships as well. I knew that forgiving her was the right thing to do, but I did not know how to start.
To begin the process of forgiveness, I had to understand why my grandmother's behavior had hurt me so much. I realized that I had been expecting her to act a certain way, and when she did not meet those expectations, I felt disappointed and hurt. I also recognized that I had not communicated my feelings effectively to her, which had led to the situation getting worse. I needed to take responsibility for my role in the situation.
Once I had come to these realizations, I was able to approach my grandmother with an open heart and mind. I apologized for my disrespectful behavior and explained how her actions had made me feel. We had a heartfelt conversation, and she shared her own perspective on the situation. It was a turning point in our relationship, and we were able to move forward with a greater understanding of each other.
Forgiving my grandmother was not easy, but it was necessary for both of us to heal and move forward. It took time and effort, but in the end, it was worth it. I learned that forgiveness is a powerful act of kindness that can bring about healing and peace, even in the most challenging situations